📖 Tutorial B Beehiiv

A Hands-On beehiiv Walkthrough

Launch your first newsletter, set up a referral program, and monetize with ads — all in beehiiv, step by step.

30 min
Est. Time
Intermediate
Difficulty
$42/mo
Cost
CreatorStack Team
Author

A Hands-On beehiiv Walkthrough

beehiiv is a newsletter platform built by former Morning Brew engineers. It handles subscriptions, email delivery, referral programs, and ad monetization in one dashboard. This walkthrough gets you from zero to first published issue with monetization enabled.

Step 1: Create Your Publication

  1. Go to beehiiv.com and sign up (free plan works to start)
  2. Click Create Publication
  3. Enter your newsletter name, tagline, and description
  4. Choose a subdomain (e.g., yournews.beehiiv.com) — you can connect a custom domain later on the Scale plan
  5. Pick a category — this helps beehiiv’s recommendation engine surface your newsletter

Your publication page is live immediately. This is where new subscribers land when they sign up.

Step 2: Design Your Subscription Widget

beehiiv generates a subscribe form you can embed anywhere:

  1. Go to Website → Subscribe Form
  2. Customize the headline and button text — keep it specific (e.g., “Get one actionable growth tactic every Tuesday” beats “Subscribe to my newsletter”)
  3. Choose a form style: inline, popup, or embedded
  4. Copy the embed code and paste it into your website, link-in-bio, or social profiles

Conversion tip: The subscribe form headline is your #1 conversion lever. Test 3 variants in the first month. A specific promise + cadence + audience signals outperforms generic CTAs by 2-5x.

Step 3: Write Your First Issue

  1. Go to Posts → New Post
  2. beehiiv’s editor is block-based: add text, images, dividers, buttons, and code blocks
  3. Write your issue — aim for 500-1500 words for a standard newsletter
  4. Use the Preview button to see how it renders on desktop and mobile
  5. Set a subject line and preview text (the two lines recipients see before opening)

Structure that works: One main story or insight → 2-3 quick links/resources → one CTA (reply, share, or sponsor mention). Keep it scannable with short paragraphs and bold key phrases.

Step 4: Set Up the Referral Program

beehiiv’s built-in referral system is its killer feature — it drove Morning Brew’s growth:

  1. Go to Boosts → Referral Program
  2. Enable the program
  3. Set milestone rewards:
    • 1 referral: Unlock a free resource (PDF, template, checklist)
    • 3 referrals: Mention in a future issue
    • 10 referrals: Free 1-on-1 consultation or exclusive content
  4. Design the referral email — this is what subscribers see when they share. Keep it short: “You’ve referred X people. You’re Y away from [reward].”
  5. beehiiv auto-generates unique referral links for every subscriber

The key is making the first milestone easy (1 referral = immediate reward). This kicks off the viral loop.

Step 5: Enable Ad Monetization

beehiiv runs an ad network that matches sponsors with your newsletter:

  1. Go to Boosts → Ad Network
  2. Apply — beehiiv reviews your publication (typically requires 1,000+ subscribers)
  3. Once approved, set your ad rates: beehiiv suggests CPMs based on your subscriber count and open rate
  4. Choose ad placement: top of issue, middle, or bottom
  5. beehiiv handles sponsor matching, creative, and payment — you just approve or decline

Revenue benchmark: Newsletters with 5,000 subscribers and 40%+ open rates typically earn $50-200 per sponsored placement. Weekly frequency = 4 ad slots per month.

Step 6: Import Existing Subscribers

If you’re migrating from another platform:

  1. Go to Subscribers → Import
  2. Upload a CSV (columns: email, name, signup date)
  3. beehiiv automatically suppresses bounced emails
  4. For Mailchimp/ConvertKit migrations, use beehiiv’s direct import tools

Important: Only import subscribers who explicitly opted in. Importing purchased lists violates beehiiv’s TOS and tanks your deliverability.

Step 7: Schedule and Send Your First Issue

  1. In the post editor, click Schedule
  2. Pick a send time — for B2B newsletters, Tuesday-Thursday 7-9 AM EST works best. For consumer newsletters, Sunday morning or weekday evenings.
  3. Choose your segments: send to all, or filter by signup date, engagement, etc.
  4. Click Schedule — beehiiv queues the send
  5. After sending, check Analytics within 24 hours for open rate, click rate, and subscriber growth

First-issue benchmark: A 30%+ open rate is solid for a new list. Below 20% suggests your subject line or audience targeting needs work.

What This Workflow Produces

MilestoneResult
Publication live~5 min
Subscribe form embedded~5 min
First issue written~15 min
Referral program active~5 min
Ad monetization enabled~5 min (pending approval)
Total setup~35 min

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Generic subject lines — “Newsletter Issue #1” gets 15% opens. “The one metric that killed our Q3” gets 45%.
  • No referral program from day one — you’re leaving 30-50% of potential growth on the table. Enable it before you send issue #1.
  • Waiting for 10,000 subscribers to monetize — beehiiv’s ad network accepts publications at 1,000. Start early.
  • Long issues — if your newsletter takes more than 5 minutes to read, engagement drops. 500-1500 words is the sweet spot.

Pro Tips

  1. Use beehiiv’s survey feature — ask new subscribers one question on signup (e.g., “What’s your biggest challenge?”). This data shapes your content.
  2. Segment by engagement — after 3 months, create a segment of subscribers who haven’t opened in 30 days. Send them a re-engagement issue or a different content angle.
  3. A/B test subject lines — beehiiv supports sending two subject lines to 10% of your list, then sending the winner to the remaining 90%.
  4. Pin your referral program — mention it in every issue’s footer. “Refer 3 friends to unlock [X]” is a proven CTA.
  5. Track cross-promotions — use beehiiv’s recommendation network to cross-promote with similar newsletters. It’s free growth.